Cannon Stats

Cannon Stats

Adam's Player Rankings

Box-to-Box Rankings: Who’s standing out, and who’s struggling?

Ranking the best of the best using the ADAM 2.0 formula

Adam Rae Voge's avatar
Adam Rae Voge
Nov 17, 2026
∙ Paid
Myles Lewis-Skelly nominated for Golden Boy Award | Arsenal FC Official  Website | Arsenal.com

At some point, football decided that midfielders should be able to do absolutely everything, and we’ve all just sort of gone along with it.

Win the ball. Keep the ball. Progress the ball. Create chances. Score goals. Cover for the fullback who’s wandered 60 yards upfield. Chase down the winger who just breezed past said fullback. Do it all again three days later.

And heaven forbid you have the audacity to be particularly good at only one or two of those things.

The box-to-box midfielder is, in theory, football’s ultimate generalist. In practice, it’s become a catch-all term for about six different types of player who happen to spend a reasonable amount of time in the middle third of the pitch.

Some are glorified defensive midfielders with a little more license to roam. Others are attacking midfielders who occasionally remember they’re allowed to tackle. And then there are the genuine all-action types who seem determined to personally participate in every possession, whether their teammates appreciate it or not.

Naturally, I’ve decided to rank them all together.

The ADAM model helps make sense of the chaos, identifying young midfielders whose statistical production stands out across the various responsibilities of the position. That produces some familiar names, some considerably less familiar ones and a few results that might have you questioning either the model’s judgment or my understanding of what a box-to-box midfielder actually is.

Both are fair.

The important thing is that we’re looking for players capable of influencing matches in more ways than one, even if they go about it very differently. And while I reserve the right to disagree with my own rankings, I’m not going to start moving players around just because the results look a little strange. Otherwise, what’s the point of having a model?

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Scott Willis.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Scott Willis · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.